Research: what do the cards say?

by Roberta Palumbo 13.05.16

Where are we? Where are we going? What do we need to get there? These were some of the burning questions considered at the EU scientific workshop on bee health and sustainable pollination held in Parma recently.

Experts from EU institutions and agencies, and academics involved in EU-funded research projects exchanged views on priorities for research under the European Commission’s Horizon 2020 framework. The discussions, which are captured in a report available on the EFSA website, should further support the efforts EFSA is making to develop a holistic approach to the risk assessment of multiple stressors and bees.

A main discussion point was the identification of research gaps in the areas of bee health and pollination. The results of an online survey provided the basis for an interesting debate on how research recommendations should be prioritised.

The expert knowledge elicitation (EKE) tool was used to gather information. The purpose of EKE is to gather information in order to solve a problem, make a decision or to obtain greater understanding of a phenomenon (you can find out more from EFSA’s guidance document on EKE). In this instance, we used the tool to try to reach consensus on research priorities for bee health and pollination. 

The EKE allowed members of each group to reflect on their problem framing. At the same time, everyone in the group could compare their judgements and attitudes with others in the group.

Using “priority cards”, the experts then ranked the proposed research recommendations according to two criteria: (i) to promote apiculture and sustainable pollination and (ii) to increase understanding of bee biology and interactions at the ecosystem level.

The results were processed using the R statistical software environment. Summary statistics (e.g. median, deviations) were generated and visual outputs (e.g. boxplots) were provided summarising the results of the ranking exercise for each of the two criteria. These visualisations formed the basis for a final discussion.

The research area with the highest average priority score was the need for data to conduct chemical risk assessments (i.e. residue levels in bee matrices, species sensitivity, dose-response relationships, toxicokinetics, toxicodynamics for chemicals, contaminants and veterinary products, and metabolites) in different bee life stages/castes/sexes and under different conditions (e.g. diet, temperature).

Please take a look at the report and let us know what you think.

Roberta Palumbo is a trainee in EFSA’s Assessment and Methodological Support Unit.

Back to blog

Add new comment

This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and prevent automated spam submissions.
1 + 6 =

Join the conversation

  • # Efsa4Bees
    Bernhard Url

    Advanced modelling supports keeping bees healthy #BeeHealth #EFSA4bees https:// twitter.com/Methods_EFSA/s tatus/827438918010290176   …
  • # Efsa4Bees
    Mariya Gabriel

    @EFSA_EU launched a European wide project 2 monitor health of #honeybee colonies. #EFSA4Bees We'll work together! @EPIntergroup_SD https:// twitter.com/EFSA_EU/status /790874736117084161   …
  • # Efsa4Bees
    Cengiz Taş

    Bilim adamları bir bal arısı kolonisinin sağlığını nasıl değerlendirebilir? #arısağlığı #balarısı #Efsa4Bees https:// twitter.com/EFSA_EU/status /790874736117084161   …
  • # Efsa4Bees
    EFSA

    Understanding how environmental stressors such as #ClimateChange can affect #bees #Efsa4Bees http:// bit.ly/2dFFX4D   pic.twitter.com/R582rp85e3
  • # Efsa4Bees
    www.cosasdeabejas.es

    Another step towards healthy bees | #Efsa4Bees http:// fb.me/NFblTgZ1  
  • # Efsa4Bees
    EFSA

    What are the main chemical stressors affecting #bees? Check out #Efsa4Bees blog http:// bit.ly/2dFDEil   pic.twitter.com/BbvXLF4VJp
  • # Efsa4Bees
    EFSA

    Want to know more about our work on #bees and #BeeHealth? Follow the #EFSA4bees blog http:// bit.ly/2cQriEp   pic.twitter.com/b812LnMEpL
  • # Efsa4Bees
    EFSA

    How can scientists assess the health of a #honeybee colony? Read our new blog post. #Efsa4Bees http:// bit.ly/2eMYa1i   pic.twitter.com/M3qxWuk1A6
  • # Efsa4Bees
    baRo

    RT @EFSA_EU What are the main biological stressors affecting #Bees? #Efsa4Bees infographic http:// bit.ly/2dwOCuN   pic.twitter.com/wdRsmbLOpm
  • # Efsa4Bees
    MEPs GERB/EPP - BG

    -@GabrielMariya: Хармонизацията в събирането и анализа на данни е ключова за опазване здравето на пчелите #EFSA4Bees http:// gerb-epp.info/1IU3  

Join the conversation