Another step towards healthy bees

by Frank Verdonck 25.10.16

How can scientists assess the health of a honeybee colony?  A piece of work we have just completed at EFSA helps to answer that question. The outcome of the HEALTHY-B project is a toolbox that can be used by anyone seeking to assess bee health “holistically” i.e. taking into account chemical, biological and physical stressors. The toolbox has already been used in EFSA’s MUST-B project to generate a conceptual model for assessing the risk to honeybee colonies from exposure to pesticides under different scenarios of combined stressors and factors.

The toolbox will also be used to design the collection of data required to feed this model and it has the potential to be used beyond EFSA’s activities. For instance, it could be used to develop a “health status index” to monitor and compare honeybee health over time across geographical space, to identify key predictors of change in honeybee health and to assess the effect of pesticides on bee health within a geographical location.

So how did we build the toolbox? Firstly, the characteristics of a healthy managed honeybee colony were agreed among bee scientists and stakeholders such as representatives of beekeepers, non-governmental organisations and industry representatives.

In essence, a honeybee colony is considered healthy when its demographic structure, behaviour and production of bee products is adequate in relation to the annual life cycle and geographic location and there is provision of pollination services. This is an important achievement since consensus has been obtained that the presence of low levels of one stressor (e.g. a virus) in a colony might not be sufficient to classify that colony as “not healthy”.

The identified characteristics of a healthy colony were then used as the basis for a hierarchical approach to identify which “indicators” (biotic components) and “factors” (abiotic components) could be measured to assess the health status of a colony.

A workshop with around 55 experts (scientists, risk assessors, risk managers and stakeholder representatives) was held in April 2016 to identify relevant scientific evidence that had not yet been considered by the working group and to discuss harmonisation of measurements and reporting. The methods most suitable for implementation in field surveys across the EU were identified. However, it is clear that efforts are required to further harmonise and validate these before they can be widely applied and results compared between regions.

Finally, the HEALTHY-B working group described the key considerations to take into account when designing a survey on bee health and provided options for data analysis.

Overall, this scientific opinion represents another step forward towards improved data collection, reporting and analysis across the EU that will facilitate risk assessments on bee health by national and European risk assessment bodies. Further engagement and collaboration amongst institutions and stakeholders will be essential for us to continue the journey towards measuring and managing the health status of bees.

Frank Verdonck is a scientific officer at EFSA.

Back to blog

Comments

I think it's a meaningful tool for the researcher and bee keeper if tool is finished. As a master from the institute of Apicultural research, my job is risk assessment and food safety consultation. I am very interested in the project when i saw you posts on the website. I and my teacher have done a lot of task which want to assess bee colony safety before I graduated in 2015.6 If you and your work group want to expand the scope of the tool's application including Asia or/and China. I think we can give you the help you need. I can also invite my teacher to take part in this project. If you have any opinions , please feel free to tell me.
Name of organisation: 
CAAS bee research institution (China)

Add new comment

This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and prevent automated spam submissions.
3 + 0 =

Join the conversation

  • # Efsa4Bees
    Elena Maestri

    #Bees under attack. Can science solve the problem? #Efsa4Bees http://www. efsa.europa.eu/interactive_pa ges/bees/BeesUnderAttack   …
  • # Efsa4Bees
    Luís Ferreirim

    Las abejas bajo amenaza http://www. efsa.europa.eu/interactive_pa ges/bees/BeesUnderAttack   … #SOSabejas #Efsa4bees
  • # Efsa4Bees
    Luís Ferreirim

    #Bees under attack. Can science solve the problem? #Efsa4Bees #SOSbees http://www. efsa.europa.eu/interactive_pa ges/bees/BeesUnderAttack   …
  • # Efsa4Bees
    ALBA PUIGPIQUE

    #Bees under attack. Can science solve the problem? #Efsa4Bees http://www. efsa.europa.eu/interactive_pa ges/bees/BeesUnderAttack   …
  • # Efsa4Bees
    Jornadas Avesa

    #Bees under attack. Can science solve the problem? #Efsa4Bees http://www. efsa.europa.eu/interactive_pa ges/bees/BeesUnderAttack   …
  • # Efsa4Bees
    Bernhard Url

    Advanced modelling supports keeping bees healthy #BeeHealth #EFSA4bees https:// twitter.com/Methods_EFSA/s tatus/827438918010290176   …
  • # Efsa4Bees
    edoardo carnesecchi

    "Let's keep the bees alive"...#Efsa4Bees Proud to be part of this valuable working group at @EFSA_EU http:// bit.ly/2eLVRwS  
  • # Efsa4Bees
    Mariya Gabriel

    @EFSA_EU launched a European wide project 2 monitor health of #honeybee colonies. #EFSA4Bees We'll work together! @EPIntergroup_SD https:// twitter.com/EFSA_EU/status /790874736117084161   …
  • # Efsa4Bees
    Cengiz Taş

    Bilim adamları bir bal arısı kolonisinin sağlığını nasıl değerlendirebilir? #arısağlığı #balarısı #Efsa4Bees https:// twitter.com/EFSA_EU/status /790874736117084161   …
  • # Efsa4Bees
    EFSA

    Understanding how environmental stressors such as #ClimateChange can affect #bees #Efsa4Bees http:// bit.ly/2dFFX4D   pic.twitter.com/R582rp85e3

Join the conversation